Over in New Zealand, Top of the Pops recordings were originally issued on a local version of the Hallmark label. Then, in the mid-1970s, Music World took over - the label having been created by budget record entrepreneur, Hoghton Hughes.
Before and after the switch, New Zealand tended not to simply re-issue the UK albums, but instead create their own collections, many of which plugged specific artists in the titles - so, for example, we find albums with novel names such as, 15 Hits of Slade, T Rex, Sweet, 20 Hits of Abba and Other Great Groups, and 20 Hits of the Wombles and Other Pops for Children.
All good fun, of course, and fitting in with these was the 1973 LP, The Top of the Poppers Present Elvis Gold: 16 of The King's Greatest Hits. Here's the cover:
This album was issued by Hallmark New Zealand, before Music World became involved. What's odd, is that even by the close of 1973, The Top of the Poppers only had 13 cover versions of Elvis hits to compile. Yet the album promises 16 titles - so how did they do that? The answer may surprise you - the album contains only three Top of the Pops recordings ("Polk Salad Annie"; "I'm Leavin'" and "Burning Love"). The rest of the tracks? One was borrowed from Hallmark's Revived 45s album (and was previously issued as a 45 on the Embassy label) - namely, "Surrender" - but the other 12 consist of the whole of this LP:
Yes, indeed. The bulk of the New Zealand album purporting to be by the Top of the Poppers actually had nothing to do with them! For those who don't know, Ross McManus was a modestly successful singer better known today for the fact that he was Elvis Costello's father. (This album was once re-issued on CD as Elvis's Dad Sings Elvis!)
(Bear with us, we're getting to the Alan Caddy bit...)
Come 1975, the Music World label had superseded Hallmark New Zealand, so far as Top of the Pops was concerned, and among the many interesting records which were issued, was this one - The Top of the Poppers Present Elvis' 20 Golden Hits.
Now, the proprietors of this blog, and the Top of the Pops fan website, have known about the LP for several years. But without full scans of the cover and labels, we did not know the track listing - until now. Buying Top of the Pops albums from such far-flung places is an expensive hobby, so when a copy turned up on Ebay from a UK seller, at a bargain price, we felt we should snap it up. What we discovered came as a surprise...
This LP contains all the material on the earlier New Zealand record, but contains four additional tracks: "Promised Land"; "Fool"; "You Don't Have To Say You Love Me" and "Rags To Riches". All of these songs were to be found on earlier Top of the Pops albums, so one might suppose they were the source.
Well in fact, that was true for three of them - "Promised Land"; "Fool" and "Rags To Riches". But when it comes to "You Don't Have To Say You Love Me", the Music World label eschewed the Poppers' recording from volume 15, and substituted a completely different soundalike cover version. Some intrepid detective work (ie, we listened to it) revealed this is none other than the recording by Alan Caddy, which was originally released in 1971 on the following Avenue label LP:
So what's the deal? We have to confess, we have no idea. Firstly, there's no obvious reason why the bona-fide Top of the Pops version would be ignored; and secondly, how did Music World manage to get the master tape of Alan Caddy's recording? And could the switch somehow have been a mistake? It's hard to see how!
Whatever the story, this is a possibly unique example of an Alan Caddy track being issued under the name The Top of the Poppers!
We might also mention that research into overseas releases is not always easy, and it's often the case that one discovery leads to more. In this instance, we were able to identify three other Top of the Poppers releases from the listing on the back:
Hopefully, one day, copies of these will also surface. Maybe they too hold surprises for us...
July 2018. We couldn’t let this time pass without marking a
very important anniversary: Top of the Pops, the best and most famous series of
cover version albums is 50 years old! It would go on to enjoy some 92 standard
editions, not to mention copious spin-off releases, but here we will focus on
the first of them: Top of the Pops volume 1.
We don’t know the exact release date for this debut LP, but
it was right around now, five decades ago, that it hit the bargain record racks
of Britain.
Let’s start by listing the tracks, and where the original
versions got to in the singles charts:
Young Girl – Originally a hit for The Union Gap Featuring
Gary Puckett (No. 1)
My Name Is Jack – Originally a hit for Manfred Mann (No. 8)
Can't Take My Eyes Off You – Originally a hit for Andy
Williams (No. 5)
Blue Eyes – Originally a hit for Don Partridge (No. 3)
Something Here In My Heart – Originally a hit for The Paper
Dolls (No. 11)
Jennifer Eccles – Originally a hit for The Hollies (No. 7)
Do You Know The Way To San
Jose – Originally a hit for Dionne Warwick (No. 8)
I Can't Let Maggie Go – Originally a hit for Honeybus (No.
8)
Lovin' Things – Originally a hit for Marmalade (No. 6)
Where Is Tomorrow – Originally a hit for Cilla Black (No.
39)
La La La – Originally a hit for Massiel (No. 35)
Boy – Originally a hit for Lulu (No. 15)
Top of the shop is “Young Girl”, which had been number 1 for
most of June 1968. Here’s the Top of the Pops version, the very first thing
most purchasers would have heard when their new LP smashed down onto the
turntable, and the automatic arm jerked its way across to the vinyl…
Top of the Pops, of course, was not the first such series to
launch. Apart from mfp’s ‘Hits’ albums, the most important competition came
from the Marble Arch label, and their ongoing Chart Busters series, which
happened to hit instalment number three right around now. So, along with Top of
the Pops volume 1, buyers had the choice of the following LP:
Note how it too contained a version of “Young Girl”. Top of
the Pops were, of course, keenly aware of this rival offering, and it’s
interesting to read the sleeve notes on the back of the album, which take a sly
dig at the Chart Busters series:
Welcome to the 'Pop'
scene, here we present a wonderful bunch of 'Pop' goodies. All the songs on
this record are 'Chart-Busters' and we take great pleasure in reproducing them
for you using the swinging-est bunch of talent on the scene. Switch on and we
dare you to try and SIT through both sides.
In terms of recording Top of the Pops, it seems the early
editions were made at Marquee Studios in Soho,
under direction of Bruce Baxter. We once heard from the engineer on that very
first edition, Gery Collins, who recalled his work on volume 1 and the next few
editions which followed:
“I engineered the first TOTP album. To help date it, I know ‘Do
You Know the Way to San Jose’,
was on it. I'd only been with the Marquee for about nine months when Allan
booked us. The studio then really was stretching its facilities to burst to accommodate
such a large session. In fact, I remember the session men were in the studio and
the backing singers were hastily located in the adjoining studio office and
stairs up to the loo. Picture it if you can as you listen to the track…”
(and here it is, for you to do just that!)
Gery continues, “Bruce Baxter was the MD, and I believe the
arranger was called Andrew Jackman. As I stated, the basic rhythm, brass and
strings were laid down on an Ampex four-track machine. Yes, just four tracks! Sometimes
we pre-mixed the four across to three tracks of a Leevers Rich half-inch tape
machine, leaving one track free for vocals.”
The link between these recording artists and the Hallmark
label remains a little sketchy. It seems that Hallmark purchased the tapes, rather
than having funded them themselves, and set about putting the LP package
together. One conundrum Gery couldn’t solve when we asked, was how there came
to be stereo versions of some of these tracks in circulation; although the Top
of the Pops album was issued in mono, there exists a little-known LP without a
title, which was released on the Uni-Zel label at around the time, and which
contains nine of the recordings – in glorious stereo!
I asked Gery about this, but he was not sure how this
obscure LP came to be: “I’ve not heard of Uni-Zel. The original four-track
would have been mastered on half-inch tape, and mixed down, I’m pretty sure, to
mono. Allan [Crawford, the man behind the series] was a business-minded,
no-frills man. Don’t think he would bother then with stereo. At that time,
I know from contemporary engineers that stereo was not widely accepted for pop
singles as many thought the stereo detracted from the audio impact that mono
would give… maybe Hallmark leased the master to Uni-Zel and they remixed it
into stereo?”
Whatever the back-story, Hallmark needed to create a
striking cover for the forthcoming record, and when it emerged, it was housed in
a bright orange sleeve which couldn’t be missed! The cover design would become
iconic, and established a standard for cover version LPs from then on.
The man behind the design was Bill Graham, who worked for
Pickwick International and was in charge of the small creative studio, based in
Victoria Works, Cricklewood, designing the label’s regular sleeve art:
“I remember when the MD (Monty Lewis) briefed me on the
project. I had a couple of hours to come up with a design using an existing
photograph that, quote, ‘could be seen from the other side of Victoria
Station’.”
The photograph supplied to Bill was one which Pickwick had
used previously, on the US
album, The In Crowd – a collection of
original hit recordings:
Bill recalls, “The first picture, the girl in the cap, was
supplied to me. I can’t remember now in what form, but it was probably a
transparency. Most of the covers I worked on were photographed specially in a
small photographers in Gerrard Street.
The problem was that these were produced very quickly, the design studio had
limited facilities and remember it all relied on the printers re-touching
(I believe at film stage) to achieve any cut-outs, so sometimes it could be a
little crude especially with the hair (How easy it is now with computers).”
So contrary to popular belief, the models were not cut out
and stuck onto coloured backgrounds; rather, the colours were painted around them. Of course, there was an
issue with this particular photo in that Bill needed to select a bright, bold
colour, but the model’s hair was in jet-black shadow. Consequently, it was
subjected to an unusual cropping effect, to the left as we look!
This image, by the way, was re-used when the Best-of
collection form 1969 was assembled the following year. Here she is again, with her hair restored!
Key to getting the series launched was the title, Top of the
Pops. As Bill recalls, “We knew that the most important thing was the name and
its connection to the BBC program.” And apart from that photo, Bill also had to
come up with the logo for the albums:
“For the record, the font, Cooper Black, at that stage did
not have the outline I required – so I had to draw it, which I can say I did
not enjoy. I wanted it because the white and dark outline would ensure the
title would show up whatever the background.”
Thus, Bill’s idea for the style of lettering allowed any and
every variety of colour scheme to be used, which indeed it was. Bill had
immediately created a design classic, the basic template for which would remain
unchanged into the 1980s. “Nobody realised how popular it would be, and that
the series would continue so long. My format was hardly changed for many years.”
And here we are, half a century on, still celebrating that
first Top of the Pops LP. What followed is well-known. Top of the Pops ultimately
accounted for almost a hundred full albums, all freshly recorded and containing
over one and a quarter thousand individual cuts. That’s pushing a hundred
tracks a year. Check the little coloured panels on the front and you will see
lists of song titles which provide documentation of what was hot, and
occasionally what was not, in each six- or eight-week micro-era, which taken as
an entirety, charts the development of popular music through well over a
decade, bridging from the 1960s to the 1980s.
We salute Top of the Pops on this 50th anniversary, and the
people who worked behind the scenes to make it happen.
Happy Birthday Top of the Pops!
And finally, one last cut from the LP, for your delectation:
